facebook rss twitter

A win for Jack Thompson… a loss for sensibility.

by Nick Haywood on 19 June 2006, 10:26

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qaf2p

Add to My Vault: x

Zealous anti-gamer wins one...



Jack Thompson, the infamous anti-games campaigner has had a bill signed into law in Louisiana.

The bill, which is designed to prevent the rental or sale of violent videogames to minors, was unanimously approved by the Senate committee and will come into immediate effect.

Similar bills have, in the past, been halted from becoming law after being challenged by the ESA (Entertainment Software Association) on the basis of infringing the First Amendment’s protection of expression.

Whilst I for one fully support the preventing minors from playing violent videogames, I’m of the belief that like DVD and VHS before them, video games should be self-regulating. We already have in place systems to prevent the sale of violent games to minors and a further law, even in the US, is a step in the wrong direction.

Perhaps if Jack Thompson directed his energies towards reinforcing the systems already in place rather than spouting ill-informed vitriol, gamers would take him more seriously and perhaps he might even find support from the industry itself.


HEXUS Forums :: 35 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
So.. lots of “tic-tac-toe” games to be released then?
Like said in the article, certificates are there for a reason.

I wont let my 9 yr old daughter watch certain 12A cert films so why should it be any different for videogames. We bought her a PS2 for Christmas and are limiting the games she has due to content. I dont play anything on the PC at all that isnt suitable for kids whilst they are still up and about and the PC is passworded whilst not in use to stop them from gaining access to some of the games installed.

I personally think that more games should be passed to the BBFC and certified properly instead of just the recommended rating they receive. For example a new Scoby Doo game for the PS2, we know it is going to be suitable for kids but I really feel there should be an enforced certificate on them to back parents up.

I know in video rental stores employees can actually enforce the recommended certificates if they wish to try and make sure minors dont get hold of adult orientated material. If BBFC certificates were on most games at least it has to be enforced by law and should help cut down minors getting hold of titles not intended for them.

Just my personal thoughts on the matter as I have 3 kids myself.
TBH, from the wording of the Hexus article I can't see the big fuss about this. Surely this is just bringing video games into line with films?

You wouldn't want your 12 year old watching a horror film, so why should they play a horror game?
Ferral
I personally think that more games should be passed to the BBFC and certified properly instead of just the recommended rating they receive.

100% agree. I don't have kids, but I think the BBFC ratings work really well. What we also need are shop assistants who do more to either enforce the rating or make it clear to parents what the rating is. I saw a kid who looked about 8 yrs old get an 18 rated game the other day in Game - the kid deliberately covered up the (BBFC) rating with his thumb when showing the box to his dad and the shop assistant didn't say a thing about the rating at any point in the sale.
The fuss is about lawyers like Jack Thompson forcing through unnecessary legislation.

The ESRB already rate games giving clear indications on the cover of the game as to what age group the games are suitable for.

The problem comes in with Jack Thompson, who often sensationlizes a game with outlandish claims, forcing through these laws.

As I said in the article, I agree in principal with the law, but Jack Thompson, given free reign, wouldn't stop there.

This is the guy who has claimed repeatedly that FPS games are ‘simulators’ which kids use for ‘training’ before going on a High School shooting spree.

The games he cites as being these ‘murder training simulators’ include Halo, GTA and he's even had a go at Sims 2 for the nudity mod…

He has been rejected from associatiing himself with notable censorchip lobbying bodies and has even had the parents of a victims of a school shooting publicly denounce his claimed association with them.

iirc, a fund was started with the view to opening up a discussion with him over video games, but the flowers sent to him as a piece offering were forwarded, by Thompson himself, to various industry figures with the message “Discard them along with the decency you discarded long ago. I really don’t care. Grind them up and smoke them if you like.”

Have a read of his biog on Wiki